By Axel Gelfert
Covering latest literature and significant debates, A serious creation to Testimony discusses the epistemic prestige of testimony-based ideals, relates adjustments to proper advancements in different parts and provides a severe viewpoint on present and destiny learn tendencies. Devoting area to either the functions of social epistemology and the bigger conceptual problems with wisdom, Gelfert not just introduces the epistemology of testimony; he deals an up to date creation to epistemology. built with a mixture of learn questions, examples, and recommendations for extra analyzing, scholars of latest epistemology will locate this a competent consultant to learning testimony as a resource of knowledge.
Read or Download A Critical Introduction to Testimony PDF
Best epistemology books
Harold Kincaid, John Dupré, Alison Wylie (Eds. )
It has lengthy been concept that technology is our greatest wish for knowing aim wisdom, yet that, to bring in this promise, it needs to be price unfastened. issues should not so uncomplicated, despite the fact that, as contemporary paintings in technological know-how stories makes transparent. The members to this quantity examine the place and the way values are interested by technological know-how, and think about the results of this involvement for beliefs of objectivity.
"Historians of technological know-how whose paintings has led them to puzzle over their very own and their ancient actors' judgments of the relatives among worth and medical truth will locate a lot of worth right here. "--Alan Richardson, Isis
"A necessary anthology of essays by way of modern philosophers. "--Choice
"A good established and informative advent offers readers with heritage at the query of values in technology. .. . a person who's drawn to the query of values in technology. .. will locate Value-Free technology? a helpful learn. "--Lisa Gannett, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews
Chapter 1. Introduction
Part I: Case experiences
Chapter 2. truth and price, John Dupré
Chapter three. How may still Sociologists research Social difficulties? , Michael Root
Chapter four. Coming to phrases with the Value(s) of technology: Insights from Feminist technology Scholarship, Lynn Hankinson and Allison Wylie
Chapter five. comparing Scientists, Brad Wray
Part II: facts and Values
Chapter 6. proof and cost Freedom, Elliott Sober
Chapter 7. Rejecting the precise of worth unfastened technological know-how, Heather Douglas
Chapter eight. Is Logical Empiricism dedicated to the best of price unfastened technological know-how? , John Roberts
Chapter nine. confident Empiricism and the position of Social Values in technological know-how, Sherri Roush
Chapter 10. the price Ladenness of medical wisdom, Gerald Doppelt
Chapter eleven. Contextualist Morals and technology, Harold Kincaid
This ebook is a sustained defence of conventional internalist epistemology. the purpose is threefold: to handle a few key criticisms of internalism and exhibit that they don't hit their mark, to articulate a close model of a vital objection to externalism, and to demonstrate how a constant internalism can meet the cost that it fares no higher within the face of this objection than does externalism itself.
Wisdom and its Limits provides a scientific new perception of information as a type of psychological degree delicate to the knower's atmosphere. It makes an important contribution to the talk among externalist and internalist philosophies of brain, and breaks appreciably with the epistemological culture of examining wisdom when it comes to precise trust.
As one of many world's major and so much highly-acclaimed modern theorists, Christopher Norris has spent a lot of the final two decades attempting to advertise larger kinfolk and mutual knowing among the divisive analytic and continental philosophical traditions. In his new ebook, "On fact and Meaning", Norris examines key concerns within the philosophy of common sense, brain and language those who have outlined the schedule of present debate in analytic philosophy.
- The Elusive God: Reorienting Religious Epistemology
- The Philosophy of 'As If ' : A System of the Theoretical, Practical and Religious Fictions of Mankind
- Goldman and His Critics
- Knowing other-wise: philosophy at the threshold of spirituality
- The Blackwell Guide to Epistemology (Blackwell Philosophy Guides)
Additional resources for A Critical Introduction to Testimony
What matters for the purposes of our discussion here is the fact that assessing the testimony of others will often involve determining whether they are our epistemic peers, or whether they are epistemically inferior – or superior – to us. Where specialized factual knowledge is concerned, it would be misguided to rely on epistemic peers alone: in such cases, we actively seek out experts. Expert testimony is fast becoming an important element in policymaking, and even at an individual level we rely on the specialized expertise of others – for example, whenever we see our family doctor for treatment.
Chapter 2, remains a good starting point for any qualitative characterization of the various kinds of testimony we encounter in different (formal and informal) contexts. In addition to the definitional issues discussed in this chapter, a parallel debate has arisen concerning the status of testimony and knowledge as natural or social kinds. Kusch (2002a) sketches a communitarian theory that views testimony primarily as a vehicle for assigning to others the social status of ‘being a knower’; by contrast, Michaelian (2008) argues that testimony is likely a natural kind and that, for this very reason, it is likely necessarily reliable.
Content and source are thus deeply intertwined in our testimonial practices. WHAT IS TESTIMONY? 2. Kinds of reporters Just as there is a wide range of kinds of testimonial content, there is great diversity with respect to testimonial sources. As is to be expected, the kinds of reporters we encounter in testimonial exchanges will vary with the kinds of reports we expect, or hope, to receive. A first important class of testifiers consists of our epistemic peers. Recall that we earlier identified as one core feature of mundane knowledge that it concerns matters about which we can reasonably expect the vast majority of people to be competent.
A Critical Introduction to Testimony by Axel Gelfert